Sign: Carriage Driver Charged After Forcing Elderly Horse To Work To Point Of Collapse On Hot NYC Street

Published: November 16, 2023 at 11:22 PM Author: PENNY EIMS

Manhattan, NY – An elderly horse named Ryder was forced to pull a carriage on a hot August day in Manhattan. The senior horse, underweight and overheated, collapsed on the pavement and could not get back to his feet for nearly an hour.

On November 15, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin L. Bragg, Jr., announced charges against the driver who pushed Ryder to collapse on August 10, 2022. DA Bragg is charging 55-year-old Ian McKeever with one count of Overdriving, Torturing and Injuring Animals, Failure to Provide Proper Sustenance, a class A misdemeanor.

District Attorney Bragg said:

“As alleged, Ryder should not have been working on this hot summer day. Despite his condition, he was out for hours and worked to the point of collapse. All animals deserve to be treated with the utmost care and the type of abuse that Ryder allegedly suffered is unacceptable.”

The press release outlines the despicable manner in which Ryder was treated after collapsing on the street:

At approximately 5:10 p.m., Ryder collapsed on the ground in the middle of the street at West 45th Street and 9th Avenue. MCKEEVER repeatedly tried to force him to stand by pulling on the reins, yelling, and using a whip. At no point did MCKEEVER provide any water to Ryder while he was on the ground, despite the 84-degree weather. MCKEEVER initially kept Ryder attached to the carriage harness while he was lying on the ground. A member of the NYPD eventually removed the harness, allowing Ryder to fully lie down. The police officer then put ice and cold water on Ryder for 45 minutes until he was finally able to stand up.

Ryder had been working in the heat since 9 a.m., collapsing from sheer exhaustion shortly after 5 p.m. A 26-year-old, underweight horse with health problems was forced to pull a carriage full of people all day long in the heat…until he literally fell on the ground in exhaustion.

McKeever lied about Ryder’s age, telling the authorities the horse was 13 years of age when he was actually twice that age – an age when he should have been retired, not forced to work in the heat.

Justice for Ryder

Please add your name to the petition as Animal Victory seeks justice for this abused horse. Ryder’s health was poor and he ultimately had to be euthanized months after his collapse. Profits over animals have no place in society. We want to see Ian McKeever held accountable for his despicable treatment of this elderly horse, and we stand in support of Ryder’s Law, which would ban horse carriages in New York City. McKeever was charged with overdriving, torturing and injuring animals and failure to provide proper sustenance, a misdemeanor carrying up to a year in jail.

We the undersigned demand that Ian McKeever be held accountable for working Ryder to the point of collapse in the heat. This senior horse was forced to work in unacceptable conditions with no concern for his well-being. We want this man to receive the maximum punishment allowable by law for the charge of Overdriving, Torturing, and Injuring Animals, and Failure to Provide Proper Sustenance. We also stand behind the passage of Ryder’s Law, which will ban horse carriages in New York City. This petition acts as our collective endorsement for Ryder’s Law, and the maximum penalty allowed by law for Ian McKeever. 

Individuals are presumed innocent until found guilty in a court of law. Animal Victory relies upon the authorities and the court system to determine guilt or innocence.

News

DA Bragg Press Release

CBS News

NY Post

Fox News

Update 7/18/2025: Ian McKeever’s Jury Trial has been continued to July 18, 2025, at 9:00 a.m. The judge is TBD. (Case #CR-032167-23NY)

Update 4/7/2025: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney with updated signatures. 

Update 3/20/2025: The jury trial has been rescheduled to 04/10/2025, at 9:00 a.m. Case #: CR-032167-23NY.

Update 2/26/2025: Jury trial was not held or cancelled for 02/25/2025.  His next appearance is still 03/18/2025 @ 9:00 a.m. 

Update 2/24/2025: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney with updated signatures.

Update 2/17/2025: Ian McKeever’s next appearance is 2/25/2025 for a jury trial at 9:00 a.m. The Judge is TBD.

Update 8/14/2024: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney and courthouse with updated signatures.

Update 7/18/2024: Ian McKeever’s next court appearance is on 09/13/2024 at 9:00 a.m. E.S.T. The judge and the D.A.  have yet to be assigned. Case #CR-032167-23NY. 

Update 3/12/2024: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney and courthouse with updated signatures.

Update 2/09/2023: Animal Victory has learned that Ian McKeever’s next appearance is set for 04/02/2024. Judge is to be determined. 

Update 12/29/2023: Animal Victory has learned that the next appearance for this defendant is 02/07/2024. Judge is still TBD.

Update 12/2/2023: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney and courthouse.

Update 11/27/2023: The first appearance is set for 12/10/2023; the judge is still set as ‘TBD’ and in NY, the DA’s rotate. Whoever is assigned that courtroom will be on the case that day. The DA, Alvin L Bragg Jr. announced they will be prosecuting this case.

Carriage Driver Charged After Forcing Elderly Horse To Work To Point Of Collapse On Hot NYC Street

16,883 signatures = 84% of goal
0
20,000

Share This Petition

16883 SUPPORTERS


Latest Signatures
16,883 L Gill 0 Jul 29, 2025
16,882 L Gill 0 Jul 29, 2025
16,881 Siw Tikkanen Aldén 0 Jul 29, 2025
16,880 LESLIE BLAIR 0 Jul 23, 2025
16,879 Biancarosa Alfieri 0 Jul 19, 2025
16,878 Séverine SORDET 0 Jul 18, 2025
16,877 Madelein Blundred 0 Jul 18, 2025
16,876 Rosa Cabrerizo 0 Jul 18, 2025
16,875 LouEllen Gradney Please ban horse abuse. Pass Ryders Law! 0 Jul 16, 2025
16,874 Barbara Oskam 0 Jul 16, 2025
16,873 Kim Ramert 0 Jul 09, 2025
16,872 Lena Ericsson 0 Jul 04, 2025
16,871 Georgia Prunty 0 Jun 19, 2025
16,870 Dawn Gencarelli 0 Jun 10, 2025
16,869 Martine Cuisenaire 0 Jun 06, 2025
16,868 Cheri Gouer Sickening.. 0 Jun 04, 2025
16,867 Jenette Graciano 0 Jun 04, 2025
16,866 Diane Moreton poor horse. my heart breaks for her. 0 May 07, 2025
16,865 tina sahlström 0 May 02, 2025
16,864 Jacqueline Spinks 0 May 02, 2025
16,863 Kris New 0 Apr 19, 2025
16,862 Brenda Carty This must be stopped. 0 Apr 12, 2025
16,861 Denise Horning 0 Apr 12, 2025
16,860 John Baskin 0 Apr 10, 2025
16,859 Megan Ramsey 0 Apr 08, 2025
16,858 Ashley Parks 0 Apr 07, 2025
16,857 Terezinha Muller 0 Mar 28, 2025
16,856 Karen Stramaglio Misdemeanor? 0 Mar 27, 2025
16,855 Karen Norton 0 Mar 27, 2025
16,854 trish t 0 Mar 25, 2025
16,853 Carol Meade 0 Mar 20, 2025
16,852 Dia Redman 0 Mar 18, 2025
16,851 nina lim 0 Mar 17, 2025
16,850 mark poos Ian McKeever must die! Hang that evil bastard and make him bleed!!!! 0 Mar 17, 2025
16,849 valentina van dijk Poor innocent horse....I hope the evil cruel driver will burn in hell soon!!! 0 Mar 17, 2025
16,848 Danielle Agresta SCUM FILTH MUST BE PUNISHED AND FORBIDDEN NEAR ANIMALS FOR LIFE!! 0 Mar 16, 2025
16,847Anonymous 0 Mar 16, 2025
16,846 María Bórquez 0 Mar 15, 2025
16,845 Margarita Ossorio 0 Mar 15, 2025
16,844 Ma. Carolina Geisse 0 Mar 15, 2025
16,843Anonymous 0 Mar 13, 2025
16,842 Amanda Nickels 0 Mar 12, 2025
16,841 Elaine Orpe 0 Mar 11, 2025
16,840 Anne Caron 0 Mar 11, 2025
16,839 Pj Adams Seriously!!!!! He needs to spend the rest of his days in jail! Only allowed out to clean up horse crap! That poor horse. Justice for Ryder! 0 Mar 11, 2025
16,838 Di De Irvin 0 Mar 09, 2025
16,837 Angela Wolford PUNISH 0 Mar 08, 2025
16,836Anonymous 0 Mar 08, 2025
16,835 Debra Hurst 0 Mar 07, 2025
16,834 Koren Harrigan 0 Mar 07, 2025
16,833 Kathy Fujimoto 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,832 Monica Westfall 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,831 Martine Tramson 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,830 Vicki Smith 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,829 Lyn Wright 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,828 Pamela Pearson 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,827 Christopher Pearson 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,826 Kerry Piest 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,825 Beth Strachan 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,824 Karen hage Disgraceful abuse to an animal, no excuses for the conduct of this person. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,823 Sandra Mariposa 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,822 Alice Soames 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,821 Holly Loving 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,820 Marie Sekund 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,819 TOMOKO ENDO 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,818 Rebecca Sterne 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,817 Karen Lenn There was NO EXCUSE for the cruelty that poor Ryder was made to suffer. Now it's his turn. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,816 Elisabeth DIAS J ai signé contre maltraité de cheval et il est trop fatigué aussi faible, faim mais il est aucun pausé de reposer 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,815 Clarissa Marsh JAIL 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,814 deborah vandamme Whoever did this must be executed, not forgivable! 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,813 Edna Pobuda Where were the animal cops and park enforcement ! Maybe the max temperature at which carriage horses are allowed to work should be lowered from 93 degrees to 80 degrees and maybe there should be a mandatory retirement age for these horses (not slaughter) and hearty fines for violators. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,812Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,811 Linda Tarnawskyj This was cruelty at its worst. He should be incarcerated for his actions. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,810 Bob Hand 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,809 Linda Kalaskie This poor should be retired in a nice pasture somewhere. They should do away with these working horses. Between the hot pavement and cars and lack of food and water. These carriages should be banned. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,808 Patricia Sansom 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,807Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,806 Luciana da Silva 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,805 Susan J Walsh 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,804 Kathryn Raggio Jail for the real animal Ian McKeever. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,803 Daniela Najdenowa 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,802Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,801Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,800Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,799 Rusell Turner 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,798 Véronique ANDRE 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,797 Josianne Cuierrier 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,796 Michelle Hartvigsen 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,795 Lynn Pace OH MY GOD!! If it's hot for us it's going to be hotter for them!! I hope this carriage driver can never own another animal!!!! 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,794 Charla Enes 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,793 Mary Wentz 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,792 Gail Lima 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,791 Mary Ann Gray 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,790 Aimee Miller 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,789 Sharon Abbey Retire this horse to a sanctuary where he can have peace and rest for his remaining time on this earth 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,788 Keith Jamieson 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,787 Gina Ferro 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,786 Aashir Awan 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,785 Sue Saunders 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,784 Margaret Hatten 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,783 Chandra Hardaway 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,782 Janice Geller 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,781 Shelly Binkley 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,780 m w tuan 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,779 Margie Hicks Please make sure he is charged for what he did to the poor elderly horse. He needs to be in jail or prison for a good while and fined a huge fine and not to be able to get out of jail or paroled. 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,778 teresa black Ian is a greedy, disgusting human, but definitely not a man. 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,777Anonymous 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,776 Adrianne Bone 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,775 Kaley Frank 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,774 Tracy Cangelosi 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,773 Rupert Veitch 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,772 Stephanie Clark 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,771 Nora Starr Please give this greedy, evil man the maximum sentence. This poor horse should be enjoying his older years in a pasture. NOT A BOILING HOT CITY STREET. 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,770Anonymous Demand maximum penalty 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,769 Adele Knox-Roberts 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,768Anonymous 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,767 Paula Mattila 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,766 susan miklajcyk 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,765 Debbie Kimzey 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,764 Robin Fredriks 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,763Anonymous 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,762 lydie brunet 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,761 Carrie Picardi 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,760 Nicole Miller 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,759 Dee Dee Brown 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,758 Vivian Lombardozzi 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,757 Heidi Green 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,756Anonymous 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,755 Felicia Fallon 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,754 Barry & Helen Hildebrand This man has no concern for this old horse's suffering. He needs to be held accountable and permanently banned from any carriage driving with horses for life. The horse needs to be confiscated and found a new home. 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,753Anonymous Unspeakable cruelty; it’s so awful that Ryder had to endure this. Wishing him a full recovery and the maximum sentence for that irresponsible owner. 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,752 Tara Hodnett 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,751 Darlene Tonnesen 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,750 Linda F 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,749 yiola Stavridou 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,748 Julianna Giovannini 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,747 Sue Michaelis 0 Mar 02, 2025
16,746Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,745 susan salce 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,744 Allison Brooks Please Prosecute to The Fullest Extent of The Law. And I Beg of The Law to Be Harsher on The Evil Humans who Cause Such Harmful Abusive Painful Cruelty to Innocent Animals without a 2nd Thought of The Animal's Need for Compassion and Decency and Basic Simple Care. These Humans MUST Suffer MUCH HARSHER CONSEQUENCES For Their Evil Behaviors. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,743 Gloria Wood 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,742 Madeleine Galarneau 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,741 Joan Jackson Please give this scum the maximum charge for animal cruelty!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,740 Anita Solomon They should put a harness on him and let him pull the cart in the heat of the summer without any water. I am a firm believer in an eye for an eye, and maybe he would understand the severity of his actions. God bless you Ryder. I am praying that they took Ryder away from this monster. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,739Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,738 Cassandra Wills 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,737Anonymous Throw the maximum sentence at him. Ban him from horse carriage trade ! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,736 Eva Dion 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,735Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,734 Lillian Arboleda 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,733 KIM WALLER 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,732 Jodie Wolter 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,731 Casandra Kendrick 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,730 Carol Shalaew I was born and raised in Manhattan and while living there had witnessed so many incidents of cruelty to these poor horses that suffer through the searing heat of the summer days in NYC and blistering cold of the winters, plus the crippling pain in their hooves lcaused by the endless hours of walking on the concrete pavement of the City streets. I have been a horse owner for most of my life and know that horses were not meant to stand for hours, or walk for ours on concrete. Their bodies and, especially their lfragile legs and hooves belong in grass filled pastures and NOT BIG CITIES WITH POLLUTION AND CONCRETE AND FILTH. STREETS. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,729 heather ripley its time these animals were retired to go and live on farms. shame on people who support this cruel trade by taking rides on them. This man should be jailed for animal cruelty, NO EXCUSES!!!!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,728 J.B. Johnson-Allen 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,727 Wayne Nicholls 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,726 Paige Rich This man doesn’t deserve to BREATHE! MAX sentence!😡 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,725 Allyson Goff He deserves the same, if not, jail time. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,724 Susan Ancona 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,723 CYNTHIA OSTRUNIC 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,722 Robin Schkrutz 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,721 Marianne Isgur 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,720 Sherry Coffey Please convict that precious horses evil owner with maximum sentence for attempting to ki precious horse lying about age and not providing water only whip when he passed out until police came and tried help with ice and water!GUILTY.. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,719Anonymous This individual who had a responsibility to properly care for his horse, instead, abused & neglected Ryder. Ryder was being forced to provide a service he could no longer do. This individual should not be allowed by law to have any other animal in his care or provide services that exploit any animal. He needs severe jail time & fines. Please do right for Ryder. He's dead now due to being overworked and underfed. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,718 Nancy Clancy 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,717 Roberta Short ABUSERS OF ANY AGE, RACE, SEX WHO MISTREAT/INJURE/KILL ANY BREATHING LIVING ENTITY NEED TO ROT IN HELL 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,716 Benjamin Bingaman 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,715 Elaine Constantine 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,714 Thomas Pintagro 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,713 Thomas Pintagro 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,712 Michelle Myers 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,711 Terry Despot 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,710 Sal Lorello 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,709 Vasu Murti In 2016, Trump presented himself at the Republican National Convention as the "law and order" candidate. As president, Trump attacked the press. Trump tried to find dirt on his political opponent Joe Biden. Trump later resorted to "dirty tricks" to unfairly influence the outcome of an election he was afraid he might lose when he asked elected officials to find nonexistent votes in Georgia. And Trump's words incited the Insurrection where his followers were trying to prevent the results of the 2020 election from being certified... all contrary to the principles upon which our republic was founded. Nixon's "imperial presidency" pales in comparison. I don't think Trump was being lighthearted when he said in an interview, if re-elected, he'd be a dictator from day one. The Democratic Party platform should support: Animal Rights, Defending the Affordable Care Act, Ending Citizens United, Ending Marijuana Prohibition, Giving Greater Visibility to Pro-Life Democrats, Gun Control, Net Neutrality, Raising the Minimum Wage to $15 an Hour, Responding to the Scientific Consensus on Global Warming, and a Sustainable Energy Policy. Democrats for Life of America, 10521 Judicial Drive, #200, Fairfax, VA 22030, (703) 424-6663 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,708 Helen Ebersole 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,707 Peggy Bolling Mckeever should be attached to a harness and rigged to a carriage in the hot summer to pull around with an extra weight of 500 pounds. An eye for an eye. Mckeever should die. Do not pass go, no going to jail, but straight to hell. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,706 Maria Warda Give him some jail time not just a bond to get out, animals deserve better not this kind of abuse. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,705Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,704 Lenoir Kieve 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,703 Dan Faulkner 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,702 Sue Wnek Any horse that is not cared for, not fed, not watered not rested, and forced to overwork deserves to have humans be held accountable. Let's have the driver pull a carriage for a few YEARS without sufficient food, water, rest. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,701 Renee Orlandi 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,700 Marie CRILLEY It is truly appalling that the driver and owner of the horse wasn't aware of the condition of the horse. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,699 Dave Cross This horse carriage business in NYC has abused and killed horses for far too long! For some reason, the City has been dragging its feet for way too long! Please sign your contempt for this ongoing cruelty!!! With many thanks for your kindness and compassion!!👍❤️ 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,698 Dorothy Cohen With animal abuse on the rise much tougher sentences are required and checks on the chsracters of the ppl adopting 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,697 Sheila Wright Throw in jail and then throw away the key to his cell 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,696 Candance Williams 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,695 Jocelyn Hulec 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,694 Jennifer Gandee 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,693 Cheri Dougherty 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,692 Dianna Chatterton Make the POS carriage driver pull people around in that carriage in the heat until he collapse or dies! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,691 Christine -Anne Montourcy 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,690 Julie Vogel 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,689 Zulma Clark 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,688 Judd Feinerman 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,687 Denise Godsil 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,686 Sharon Barnes 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,685 Kathy Foreman This needs to be outlawed! Horses, cars and hot pavement are cruel!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,684 Sherri Nitz 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,683 Ron Tounian Be merciful to animals NOT to the perpetrators. Our legal system is corrupt like ALL the rest. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,682 Dianne Hayes 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,681 Adriana Salvador Disgusting. Should also be emphasized more that the fact the poor horse had to be euthanized, Ian deserves to be punished for a longer sentence. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,680 Christine Chudzicki 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,679 Shelley Stierli End the carriage horse carnage now!!!! Go electric!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,678 Margareta Radeschnig Bitte dem Mann die Konzession entziehen, auch ein Tierhalteverbot gehört auferlegt und Ryder bitte auf einen Gnadenhof in die wohlverdiente Rente bringen!!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,677 Cesar Moncada 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,676 Allison Tice 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,675 Lee Grieve 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,674 Karen Neil 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,673Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,672 Susan Phillips 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,671 Terri Smith Get this individual off the streets. He only did this for money so fine him millions for his greed and cruelty. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,670 Geneviève Lapoux 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,669 Kathleen Conibear 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,668 Angela Dempsey 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,667 Kathleen Lackey 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,666 Jodi Sinclair 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,665 tracy Michaloski 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,664 Lisa Meskell What a sin - someone should hook the driver up to a wagon and abuse him! Such a needless act of cruelty 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,663 Dr. Steven Walsh Punish this vicious criminal to the maximum penalty permitted by law! Also forbid him from being allowed to own an animal ever again! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,662 Joke Soto-Kleuskens 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,661 Jonalyn Irvine 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,660 Linda Campbell 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,659 Benoit Ou PITROU 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,658 C Dursun 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,657 Kimberly Pearson 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,656 BARBARA LEE Outlaw this cruelty to helpless animals. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,655Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,654 Michelle Grimes 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,653 Paula Schell 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,652 Pamela Hornick 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,651 Yvonne Hobel 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,650 Valerie Libhart Make all these animal abusers pay & suffer as all the innocent animals did.. humans disgust me! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,649 Tina Anderson Stop delaying the trial!!! Oh and the poor excuse for an owner should be hitched to the carriage and be forced to pull it in the summer with no water while being whipped. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,648 Terry Gardiner 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,647 Denise Vinas DEATH Penalty 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,646 Kathy Rheaume 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,645Anonymous This must be stopped abuse evil 😈 please President Trump stop abuse to all animals 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,644 Darlene Moore This trial has taken way too long to hold this man accountable. He killed this animal knowing full well its limitations and still continued to torture this poor horse. Harshest punishment needed! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,643 Dominique Texier 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,642 Linda Cloud This person should never be allowed to own another horse. Actually, any animal. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,641 Carole Chowen McKeever should never be allowed to own another animal. This was so sick! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,640 Wilhelmina Oshel The owner of this horse should have his horse taken from him and not be allowed to own any animals ever and be sent to jail for cruelty! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,639 Kelly Marks 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,638 Sue Gilmore 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,637 Beth Jernigan 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,636 Debra Byers 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,635 Renee Duncan YOU F**KFACE. You should go to jail for a LONG, long time. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,634 Susan Romdenne 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,633 Yautra Aspen Gay I wish I could do the same to that jerk!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,632 Patricia McCracken 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,631 Fiona Withey 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,630 Karen Rome 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,629 Anne Winskill Sling him in jail and work him relentlessly until he dies. Evil sadistic bastard 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,628 Brittney Carfora 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,627 Anne May Why waste taxpayers money. These delays are pathetic. Sling his ass in jail and forget about him 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,626 Suzanne Lelaidier 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,625 Carl Satton 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,624 Sally Perzanowski You won't like it if we pushed you to work till you drop. Stop doing this to animals who only known love in their hearts . Even after abuse 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,623 Paula Spier 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,622 Sherrie Hunt I HATE THESE PEOPLE! JAIL THIS ANIMAL ABUSER!!!!!! This horse did not deserve to live like this!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,621 Toni Williamon 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,620 Renee Simic 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,619 Denise Schauer Lock this abuser up. Carriage rides should be outlawed. This horse should be taken away from him and put in a horse sanctuary. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,618 Debra Edwards Animal abuse should be a felony. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,617 Dehlia Wright 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,616 Jessica Armijo 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,615 Tonya Andres 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,614 Pat Ander 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,613 Anya Oleynik 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,612 Kathy Gompertz 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,611 BARBARA MINTZ 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,610 Vera Marino All the carriage horses in NYC should be taking of the street, this beautiful, majestic horses don't deserve to live and work in the Streets, they deserve more. Pasture and healthy food and better living conditions. Please God help them!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,609 Gigi Cunliffe This greedy, cruel nonhuman should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,608 Tracy Donolo 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,607 Alice Thomas maximum sentence 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,606Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,605 Lisanne Donohue 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,604Anonymous This is the kind of mistreatment we aren't surprised to see in poorer countries not in one of the world's richest!! Unconscionable behaviour!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,603 Margaret Sawyer 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,602 ISAIA Marie 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,601 Allan Sutter 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,600 Robert j Lopez 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,599 Esther Khan 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,598 Geraldine Smart 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,597 Tina Lewis Omg, seriously New York is such a shit hole with all these foreign people driving pedal cabs and horse carriage rides. Go back home. They have no respect for humans let alone animals. Scum of the earth. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,596 Amanda Riley 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,595 Annie Nalpas INACCEPTABLE!!! j'espère qu'il ne pourra plus avoir d'animal pour le faire travailler. Changez de métier!!!!! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,594 Trish Schoenfeld 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,593 Leslie Cullis 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,592Anonymous The incredible heat and humidity of a New York City summer was something I almost failed to survive without being able to go into air conditioned shops. Horse driven cabs don't belong there in summer or freezing winter. So sorry this lovely horse was hurt like this. They need to be banned - use motors or humans on bicycle-rickshaws instead !!!!! Children need to be taught to not allow cruelty when they see it, when they are still in SCHOOL - to make sure they are taught, if their PARENTS are not teaching them to be kind - which seems this horse owner had not been taught. How sad for a lovely horse to not enjoy the love and kindness of the human who owns him. In jail with bread and water is too good for the cruel owner. AND, ATTENTION !! WE MUST THANK THE POLICE OFFICERS WHO CAME TO HELP WITH KINDNESS - THEIR NAMES / PHOTOS SHOULD BE ON A SPECIAL LIST - IN A PUBLIC PLACE - LIKE THE LIBRARY. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,591 Sunday Kraushaar 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,590 Sherriejail time for torture of any living creature ,please. Lee 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,589 Bernadette Moriarty GROSS HUMAN.. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,588 Rafael Aedo 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,587 Steve mineau 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,586 Roberto Faria 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,585Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,584 Jody Kacyon 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,583 Irene DeAngelis 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,582 M A 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,581Anonymous The horrific treatment of these horses needs to stop! We as a society need to evolve. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,580 Floralee Condello 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,579 Ellen John 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,578 Marie DiCowden 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,577 Jill MacPhail 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,576 Daniel Bennett 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,575 Philip Tamer 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,574 Lyn Webster 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,573 Rosemary Mills 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,572 PATRICIA Guthrie 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,571 Melanie Merriken How many petitions need to be signed before this cruelty comes to an end? It is just sickening what they do to these animals. Has no one in New York a heart? 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,570 Angie Weis 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,569 Nathalie Raffy 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,568 Sonja E Hafkemeyer 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,567 Veronica Lopez 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,566 Marina Barry 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,565 Liam Whitlock 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,564 Colette Sullivan 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,563 Fiona Fleming 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,562 briana weaver 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,561 So Allen 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,560 Mary Ann Belshaw 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,559 Kathleen Daly 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,558Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,557 Antoinette Kizak 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,556 Susan Scheier This is such a tragedy. This poor horse did not deserve to be treated so brutally. 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,555 Herman Villamizar 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,554Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,553 Tiffany Kueber 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,552 Lily Lopez 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,551Anonymous 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,550 Margo Blake 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,549 Linda Weisman 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,548 Rhonda Hansen 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,547 Martine Curtis 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,546 Tara Shallenberger 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,545 Susan Davis 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,544 Diana Domantay 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,543 Michele Franklin 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,542 Leanah Bouvier 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,541 Karen Barclay 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,540 Lászlóné Abért 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,539 Chelsea Smith Way too often and way too much of this happening all over the United States! Make no mistake that this is a serious problem worldwide. No animal deserves to be treated so horribly at all. There's no excuse for any of it. Lock these people up! 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,538 paul cole 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,537 Amy Jamieson 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,536 Jody Chandler 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,535 Penny Rea 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,534 Whitney Rubin 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,533 Julia Aschenbrenner 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,532 Deborah Sheehan 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,531 Doris Ward 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,530 Kacy Harnedy 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,529 Michelle Black Starved an old horse and worked it to death. Ryder was kept in a dingy filthy stall he couldn’t turn around in… This guy bottom of thee barrel 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,528 Cynthia Porter 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,527 Melissa Walley 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,526 Jodi Dorsey 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,525 Tina Carroll 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,524 Shayna Schneider 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,523 Jem Sainto 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,522 Carrie Louise Pooley 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,521 Megan Tucillo 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,520 mary renard 0 Mar 01, 2025
16,519 gary gartner 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,518 Mary Sunderhauf 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,517 Eva Gouge 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,516 Deirdre Gately 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,515 Sharyn Beckman 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,514 Sandra Jeter 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,513 Dolly Finn 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,512 Tammy Khounlavong This is horrible. He deserves jail time. 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,511 Rose Cullingford 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,510 Paula McCarthy 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,509 E S 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,508 Carla Ellis Everyone of these carriage rides needs to be shut down because they don't give a shit about their horses just the money that they bring in! 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,507 DIANE KNYBEL horrible!~!! 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,506 Tania Menna Barreto 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,505 Elizabeth Marino 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,504 Joyce Pretzer This is a cruel life for horses. We are way beyond horse and carriages. ENOUGH ANIMAL ABUSE...NO MORE!!!!! 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,503 Dominique Barre 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,502 Cheryl Archer 😥 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,501 A. Penardo Sentencing is necessary so this man never again tortures another horse. I SUPPORT RYDER’S LAW! Stop carriage rides once and for all. 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,500 donna bucciarelli 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,499 paula johnson 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,498 Phillip Emmel 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,497 Michele Busskohl Work him until he collapses, test him the same. Put him in jail, remove the horse & ALL other animals from his care. 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,496 Jennifer Shull 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,495 Annie Laurie 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,494 Glenn Tannous 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,493Anonymous 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,492 Rachel Harris 0 Feb 28, 2025
16,491 Jo Ann Delcambre I can’t understand how these so called people can get away with such CRUETY!!!!!!!!! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,490Anonymous 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,489 Leesa Bowman Despicable!! Justice for Ryder and retirement away this horrible, cruel person, who hopefully wi get the maximum penalty and never be able to own another animal 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,488 Sandra McLaurin MAXIMUM PUNISHMENT! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,487 Linda Adamcz 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,486 Julie Camp 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,485 Gina Geneaux HORRIFIC treatment of this horse! This awful cruelty cannot go unpunished in a world class city as NYC!!!! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,484 Donna Barreto 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,483 Pamela Alund 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,482 Jennifer Valentine 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,481 Carole Powell Ian McKeever should be prosecuted to the fullest 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,480 Bonnie Welch I am fed up that our officials ignore this violent and cruel issue. The most animal abusers get is a slap on the hand with probation and fines! THAT STOPS NOTHING!, IN FACT ITS AN OPEN INVITATION NEW SCUM BAGS JOIN IN EVERY DAY. The crime to do with NO consequences!! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,479 Paula Boyer 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,478 Judith Perlstein This is Animal Cruelty & owner should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of law!!! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,477 Amy Lerner 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,476 susanne frii 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,475 Leandra Awad 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,474 Anne Havard 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,473Anonymous 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,472 Rosemary Watabe 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,471Anonymous 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,470 Barbara Tapia 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,469 Robert Hallas 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,468 Su Lewis Hope horse is safe away from this cruel owner 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,467 Jennifer Fort 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,466 jessica h 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,465Anonymous This is happening all over and needs to be stopped! Lock him up! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,464 Kathy Mora Aside from the measley one year jail sentence, he needs to be banned from owning any animals for profit, pay a sever fine, and endless hours of community service. 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,463 Michael Cavallaro 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,462 Jane Kristersson This "case" can be solved by banning carriage driving In NYC. What I can't understand is that the court system in NYC is so backed up that it cannot handled for at least 3 years. What other case are being postponed? 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,461 Susan Steward Sadism: Some people enjoy causing suffering to others. Sociopathy, is a mental health condition in which a person consistently shows no regard for right and wrong and ignores the rights and feelings of living beings. 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,460 Lourdes Willems Horrible! People like this should be put in jail for life!! same thing should be done to him! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,459 Lourdes Willems Horrible! People like this should be put in jail for life!! same thing should be done to him! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,458 Denise Maurer 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,457 Debbie Darby 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,456 Luette Guilmette 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,455 Jennifer Derr He should be subjected to the same. As he is older, he should be in the hot sun working hard without food or water for hours. See how he likes it. 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,454 Catherine Mazzoni 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,453 TOMOKO ENDO 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,452 Marcy Chapman 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,451 Suzy Miller 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,450 Maria Maxwell 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,449 Michelle OConnor 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,448 Blair D 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,447 Foster Jodie This is horrific and for it to happen in New York!!! Horse and carriage rides need to be banned anyway. Despicable man. Even when he saw his horse had collapsed, he carried on whipping him. What a sadist. LOCK HIM UP AND BAN HIM FROM EVER OWNING ANIMALS. Animal cruelty is horrific. It’s a sickening abuse of power over the innocent. Worse, the horse was giving him a living and the low life that he is still tortured him. It’s a good thing, for his sake, I wasn’t there to witness it. AHGGGHHHH!!!! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,446 Nancy Locking 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,445 Evan Oakley What was done to Ryder is heartbreaking and sickening. As a New Yorker, I have had enough of not just the utter callousness of these drivers, but frankly (and I am strong supporter of unions) their union which stands obstinately in the way of ending the rampant abuses in this anachronistically abusive business. A first step is real accountability for the drivers who so cruelly disregard the most basic well being of these sensitive and terribly abused horses. Forcing horses to pull carriages amid busy, loud, often chaotic midtown and Central Park traffic is insane. Sadly, what was done to Ryder is all too common. We have seen horse after horse suffer and go down, from heat, from extreme stress, and from collisions. The proliferation of e-bikes and scooters makes these carriages even less tenable. Many other large and iconic cities have already banned carriages. What Ian McKeever did was particularly sickening. He forced twenty-six year old, underweight Ryder to pull carriages in high heat, from 9-5. He persisted in trying to pull Ryder up to suffer more. He yelled at him. He whipped him. He did not give Ryder any water, nor did he release his harness. It took the intervention of NYPD officers to release his harness and give Ryder water and ice. McKeever lied about Ryder's age. I've worked with horses in the later twenties (at a sanctuary) and that is far too old an age to subject a horse to labor, let alone pulling carriages amid city pollution, heat, crowds, and noise. After this horrific cruelty, the carriage company essentially disappeared Ryder and hid him from public scrutiny, oversight, and protection. Unsurprisingly, Ryder soon had to be euthanized. I don't advocate it, because it's a danger to all involved, but the public is going to start intervening if these abuses don't stop. It's only a matter of time. McKeever needs to be put away. But we also need to stop the insanity of horse drawn carriages in the middle of Manhattan. Ryder suffered horribly before he died. But so many other horses have suffered terribly, too. We must end this, before we're forced to read about another Ryder. Thank you again for prosecuting this case and for pursuing serious charges. 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,444 Antonio Lucchetto 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,443 Catalina Elena Todirica 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,442 Jennifer Harborne 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,441 Sandra Eddy 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,440 Ella Holland 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,439 Elena Fowler 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,438 Sharon Maxey 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,437 Diana Lynn 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,436 Sheryl Mccabe An8mal Abuse Has To Stop! 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,435Anonymous 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,434 Kim Ippolito Cruel 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,433 Darlene Dynega 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,432 Joyce Shovah 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,431 Julia Ortiz 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,430 Kim Waybourn This is unacceptable, allowing this court case to go on for 2 years already. This disgusting human named Mckeever should be tortured for 26 years until he can no longer walk or do anything for that matter, with no water or food and no medical help. He deserves nothing less 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,429 Robin morgan MENTAL ILLNESS or not, If a person cannot tell the difference between right & wrong or CONTROL THEIR IMPULSES, they SHOULD NOT LIVE AMONGST SOCIETY.....There is NO CURE for a SOCIO PATH. PROSECUTE to the FULLEST EXTENT of the LAW......Fine of $20,000....PRISON TIME 10 years, NO PLEA DEALS....NO TIME OFF for good behavior....No animal ownership for their lifetime.... Better yet...Do the same thing to this person that he did to the animal....MAKE AN EXAMPLE of this person. 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,428 Tammie Winburn 0 Feb 27, 2025
16,427 Deborah Knox Jail time for animal cruelty. Stop this evil practice 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,426 Mary Romanek 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,425 Colette Winslow 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,424 Duree Douglas This pos person(?) should be banned for life 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,423 DENISE COGIL Shut these carriage horse things down right now.This is cruel and unjust punishment for these poor animals probably 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,422 Larry Wasek 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,421 Rene Concepcion 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,420Anonymous Punish him!! 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,419Anonymous The owner should be made to pull the carriage. This is why you should NEVER patronize these. 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,418 Annie Hinds 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,417 Angela Torres 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,416 Regina Biggs 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,415 Cheryl Pierson 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,414 Dianne Christ 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,413 Donna Stone 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,412 Kimberly dodd 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,411 Leigh Ashman 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,410 Pamela Speagle 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,409Anonymous 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,408 Alex Harris 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,407 Michael Silvera 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,406 Stefanie Ribustello 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,405 Janis Meyers 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,404 Dawn Freeman Animals are not created for our own pleasure or abuse. 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,403Anonymous 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,402 M FERGUSON 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,401 Glenn Fuss Please charge this man and throw him in jail. He is despicable. 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,400 Melanie Ebron 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,399 Vivian Leung 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,398 Sandra Melton 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,397 Madeleine Hoffman 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,396Anonymous 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,395 Cheryl McKinney 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,394 Alisha Tampalini 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,393 Valetta Calhoun Monster! 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,392 Diane McCrimmon Greed and cruelty are absolutely not a good combination for any animal! This poor horse! This man should be required to pull four people from 9:00 to 5:00 in the New York heat and learn a lesson 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,391Anonymous 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,390 Loretta Churchill 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,389 Daniel Sylvester Please see justice for Ryder. 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,388 Megan Steinfath Lock this person up for good…they are a danger to society 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,387 Jeniffer Graham 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,386 Connie Anasis 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,385 Sonja Viilo 0 Feb 26, 2025
16,384 Garnet Dally 0 Feb 26, 2025