Teen Stole Horse Recovering From Broken Hip, Rode Him Until He Couldn’t Stand, Then Dumped Him In Creek To Drown

Published: January 24, 2022 at 09:50 PM Author: PENNY EIMS

Selma, Alabama – A despicable, and heartwrenching act of cruelty recently took place in Alabama, leaving a former racehorse dead in a tragic and unthinkable manner. The horse’s name was Yankey, and his owner, Vicky Stoudenmire, was nursing him back to health after he broke his hip. But before Yankey was healed, a 17-year-old broke through fencing at Stoudenmire’s property and whisked the recovering horse away.

Stealing Yankey was terrible, but what the teen did next is horrific. A video that was posted to social media revealed how Yankey was treated after being taken from his home. The horse who was not supposed to have anyone on his back during his recovery was ridden by the teen…and he was forced to run.

In the footage, a teen can be seen taking Yankey for a “joy ride,” and at one point, racing a car to see how fast the horse could run.  After a few days of running, the injured horse was too lame to stand. At this point, the teenager solicited help from 23-year-old Terrius Smith, who helped load Yankey into a trailer.

The pair took Yankey to a creek, forced him out of the trailer, and left him in the murky water to drown. Dallas County District Attorney Michael Jackson has stated that Yankey’s leg was broken because of the way he was ridden; the horse was found with a compound break above his hock.

The way that Yankey was treated before dying breaks his owner’s heart. She said, “I get sick to my stomach thinking about how much pain he was in and how he was just treated so poorly.”

The teenager is facing a second-degree theft of property and aggravated animal cruelty charge and his case will be handled in juvenile court. Smith is also charged with aggravated animal cruelty.

Please add your name to the petition today. Yankey was stolen and tortured before being dumped in a creek to die – this is an appalling crime that must not go unpunished!

We the undersigned demand that the suspects responsible for torturing and killing Yankey receive the maximum punishment allowable by law.

Note: Individuals are presumed innocent until being found guilty in a court of law. Animal Victory relies upon the authorities and the court system to determine guilt or innocence.



Selma Times Journal


Terrius Smith

Update 2/09/2024: Terrius Smith sentence was pronounced on 1/22/2024. His charge was reduced to “Receiving stolen property” a 3rd degree misdemeanor. As part of a plea agreement, he received a 13-month suspended sentence, 12-month supervised probation, pay restitution to the owner of $500. Sentence was pronounced by Honorable Collins Pettaway, Jr., Circuit Judge. P.O. Box 1225 102 Church St., Courthouse Annex Selma, AL 36702 (334) 874-2510. Animal Victory is deeply disappointed with this sentence given the extraordinary cruelty of the crime. We are, however, pleased that the case was not dismissed. 

Update 3/28/2023:  Animal Victory sent cover letter and petition to the judge.

Update 9/26/22: The felony indictment was disposed of on June 28, 2022. However, the trial began in April. The case was moved to circuit court after the indictment. The next court date is not until May 8, 2023. 

Update 8/01/2022: Animal Victory has sent 22,844 signatures to District Attorney Michael Jackson.

Update 7/07/2022: Smith was placed in the Dallas County Jail under a $15,000 bond. We have been told he has since bonded out but will have his day in court in the coming weeks. The teen’s case is being handled by the juvenile courts.  The scheduled court date is September 8.

Update: As of January 26, Animal Victory has been told that the primary person accused in this crime is 17, and because of his age, there is no information that can be released. Terrius Smith, the individual who was contacted to help, is charged with aggravated animal cruelty. Animal Victory has sent 19,073 signatures to District Attorney Michael Jackson

Prior Signatures 28,014

Teen Stole Horse Recovering From Broken Hip, Rode Him Until He Couldn’t Stand, Then Dumped Him In Creek To Drown

457 signatures = 2% of goal

Share This Petition


Latest Signatures
457 Laura S. Mar 14, 2024
456 Cathy C. Mar 13, 2024
455 Nozomi I. Mar 12, 2024
454 Virginia W. Mar 12, 2024
453 Nancy G. Mar 12, 2024
452Anonymous Pathetic Sentence! Mar 11, 2024
451 Rita B. Mar 09, 2024
450 Ashley G. Mar 09, 2024
449 John O. Mar 08, 2024
448 Nadia D. Mar 08, 2024
447 Matthew P. Mar 07, 2024
446 Cindy S. Mar 07, 2024
445 William B. This sentence by the judge is a complete travesty of justice! This thug will learn nothing by this sentence except that he can do it again and expect probation! $800 lousy dollars for punishment for the horrible pain and suffering endured by this poor horse. I hope the citizens of this community find a way to get that liberal lenient judge off the bench! Mar 06, 2024
444 Paul R. Mar 06, 2024
443 Chante' K. Mar 05, 2024
442Anonymous Mar 05, 2024
441 KAHMELIA S. Animal abuse is a crime!, why did this person just get a slap on the wrist!??? Look what he did to this horse???? He has no compassion at all!. Mar 05, 2024
440 Michele J. Mar 05, 2024
439 Billie C. This was not just a case of theft this was a case of torture and murder of an innocent animal. Why do people think that their actions of animal cruelty are ok? I plead with the court to make this person serve time for his actions instead of a slap on the wrist. May our country do better when it comes to animal abuse in any way!!! Mar 05, 2024
438 Lisbeth L. Maximum penalty for this! Put this person behind bars! Mar 05, 2024
437 Emmanuelle H. Mar 05, 2024
436 doreen r. Teens just don't care about anything else but themselves!!! It's just cruel and inhumane!!! Mar 05, 2024
435 Phyllis B. Mar 04, 2024
434 Ivana C. Mar 04, 2024
433 Mary L. Mar 04, 2024
432 Leilani P. Mar 04, 2024
431 Tina R. Stolen property and a fine!? I hate the judicial system letting these violent people go free!! How horrible for the horse and owner. Time to replace that judge! Mar 04, 2024
430 Carol R. Mar 04, 2024
429 Francis S. Mar 04, 2024
428 TRACEY H. You are a savage that ought to be put to death. You have no right to do this to an innocent creature. Mar 04, 2024
427 Maria M. Mar 04, 2024
426 Diane G. Mar 03, 2024
425 Christian V B. Mar 03, 2024
424 Helen D. Mar 03, 2024
423 Patricia F. This man's sentence is ridiculous!!! Mar 03, 2024
422 carol L. Mar 03, 2024
421 Frank H. Shame on the judge and Alabama court system for not taking wanton cruelty towards a living creature seriously. These pieces of trash will end up hurting another animal or human and end up right back in jail thanks to this callous slap on the wrist. RIP, Yankey, you didn't deserve this. Mar 03, 2024
420 Elke H. widerlich was er getan hat. das gleiche sollte ihm geschehen. oder 10-20 jahre einsperren ins härteste gefängnis der Welt Mar 03, 2024
419 Roxanne P. The poor horse went thru so much pain and then killed by this POS and then gets a slap on the wrist by the judge. This judge has no heart or compassion for animals. He probably enjoys inflicting pain and abuse on animals himself. Mar 03, 2024
418 Hogan D. Mar 02, 2024
417 Stu C. “The honorable Collins Pettaway”, my ass. Nothing honorable about this POS’ sentence the judge gave him. It. Irks me that the judge’s last name contains the word Pet. Disgusting criminal and judge. Mar 02, 2024
416 Carmie H. Mar 02, 2024
415 DARCY D. The torture and extreme cruelty this innocent animal had to endure before they killed him. They should be put in jail and hopefully they will get abused!!! Mar 02, 2024
414 Helen B. Mar 02, 2024
413 Catherine E. Mar 02, 2024
412 Donna G. Mar 02, 2024
411 jean p. ten years in jail. lousy subhuman doesnt deserve to live he is so cruel. absolutely disgusting sub human being. not fit to be in civilization ever Mar 02, 2024
410 Barbara M. This is just an injustice to the owner who absolutely, loved her horse and someone can come in her property and killed her horse! Mar 02, 2024
409 Wanda N. Mar 02, 2024
408 Robin E. Mar 02, 2024