Sign: Carriage Driver Charged After Forcing Elderly Horse To Work To Point Of Collapse On Hot NYC Street

Published: November 16, 2023 at 11:22 PM Author: PENNY EIMS

Manhattan, NY – An elderly horse named Ryder was forced to pull a carriage on a hot August day in Manhattan. The senior horse, underweight and overheated, collapsed on the pavement and could not get back to his feet for nearly an hour.

On November 15, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin L. Bragg, Jr., announced charges against the driver who pushed Ryder to collapse on August 10, 2022. DA Bragg is charging 55-year-old Ian McKeever with one count of Overdriving, Torturing and Injuring Animals, Failure to Provide Proper Sustenance, a class A misdemeanor.

District Attorney Bragg said:

“As alleged, Ryder should not have been working on this hot summer day. Despite his condition, he was out for hours and worked to the point of collapse. All animals deserve to be treated with the utmost care and the type of abuse that Ryder allegedly suffered is unacceptable.”

The press release outlines the despicable manner in which Ryder was treated after collapsing on the street:

At approximately 5:10 p.m., Ryder collapsed on the ground in the middle of the street at West 45th Street and 9th Avenue. MCKEEVER repeatedly tried to force him to stand by pulling on the reins, yelling, and using a whip. At no point did MCKEEVER provide any water to Ryder while he was on the ground, despite the 84-degree weather. MCKEEVER initially kept Ryder attached to the carriage harness while he was lying on the ground. A member of the NYPD eventually removed the harness, allowing Ryder to fully lie down. The police officer then put ice and cold water on Ryder for 45 minutes until he was finally able to stand up.

Ryder had been working in the heat since 9 a.m., collapsing from sheer exhaustion shortly after 5 p.m. A 26-year-old, underweight horse with health problems was forced to pull a carriage full of people all day long in the heat…until he literally fell on the ground in exhaustion.

McKeever lied about Ryder’s age, telling the authorities the horse was 13 years of age when he was actually twice that age – an age when he should have been retired, not forced to work in the heat.

Justice for Ryder

Please add your name to the petition as Animal Victory seeks justice for this abused horse. Ryder’s health was poor and he ultimately had to be euthanized months after his collapse. Profits over animals have no place in society. We want to see Ian McKeever held accountable for his despicable treatment of this elderly horse, and we stand in support of Ryder’s Law, which would ban horse carriages in New York City. McKeever was charged with overdriving, torturing and injuring animals and failure to provide proper sustenance, a misdemeanor carrying up to a year in jail.

We the undersigned demand that Ian McKeever be held accountable for working Ryder to the point of collapse in the heat. This senior horse was forced to work in unacceptable conditions with no concern for his well-being. We want this man to receive the maximum punishment allowable by law for the charge of Overdriving, Torturing, and Injuring Animals, and Failure to Provide Proper Sustenance. We also stand behind the passage of Ryder’s Law, which will ban horse carriages in New York City. This petition acts as our collective endorsement for Ryder’s Law, and the maximum penalty allowed by law for Ian McKeever. 

Individuals are presumed innocent until found guilty in a court of law. Animal Victory relies upon the authorities and the court system to determine guilt or innocence.

News

DA Bragg Press Release

CBS News

NY Post

Fox News

Update 2/26/2025: Jury trial was not held or cancelled for 02/25/2025.  His next appearance is still 03/18/2025 @ 9:00 a.m. 

Update 2/24/2025: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney with updated signatures.

Update 2/17/2025: Ian McKeever’s next appearance is 2/25/2025 for a jury trial at 9:00 a.m. The Judge is TBD.

Update 8/14/2024: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney and courthouse with updated signatures.

Update 7/18/2024: Ian McKeever’s next court appearance is on 09/13/2024 at 9:00 a.m. E.S.T. The judge and the D.A.  have yet to be assigned. Case #CR-032167-23NY. 

Update 3/12/2024: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney and courthouse with updated signatures.

Update 2/09/2023: Animal Victory has learned that Ian McKeever’s next appearance is set for 04/02/2024. Judge is to be determined. 

Update 12/29/2023: Animal Victory has learned that the next appearance for this defendant is 02/07/2024. Judge is still TBD.

Update 12/2/2023: Animal Victory sent petition to the attorney and courthouse.

Update 11/27/2023: The first appearance is set for 12/10/2023; the judge is still set as ‘TBD’ and in NY, the DA’s rotate. Whoever is assigned that courtroom will be on the case that day. The DA, Alvin L Bragg Jr. announced they will be prosecuting this case.

Carriage Driver Charged After Forcing Elderly Horse To Work To Point Of Collapse On Hot NYC Street

16,838 signatures = 84% of goal
0
20,000

Share This Petition

16838 SUPPORTERS


Latest Signatures
16,838 Di De I. 0 Mar 09, 2025
16,837 Angela W. PUNISH 0 Mar 08, 2025
16,836Anonymous 0 Mar 08, 2025
16,835 Debra H. 0 Mar 07, 2025
16,834 Koren H. 0 Mar 07, 2025
16,833 Kathy F. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,832 Monica W. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,831 Martine T. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,830 Vicki S. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,829 Lyn W. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,828 Pamela P. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,827 Christopher P. 0 Mar 06, 2025
16,826 Kerry P. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,825 Beth S. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,824 Karen h. Disgraceful abuse to an animal, no excuses for the conduct of this person. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,823 Sandra M. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,822 Alice S. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,821 Holly L. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,820 Marie S. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,819 TOMOKO E. 0 Mar 05, 2025
16,818 Rebecca S. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,817 Karen L. There was NO EXCUSE for the cruelty that poor Ryder was made to suffer. Now it's his turn. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,816 Elisabeth D. J ai signé contre maltraité de cheval et il est trop fatigué aussi faible, faim mais il est aucun pausé de reposer 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,815 Clarissa M. JAIL 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,814 deborah v. Whoever did this must be executed, not forgivable! 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,813 Edna P. Where were the animal cops and park enforcement ! Maybe the max temperature at which carriage horses are allowed to work should be lowered from 93 degrees to 80 degrees and maybe there should be a mandatory retirement age for these horses (not slaughter) and hearty fines for violators. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,812Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,811 Linda T. This was cruelty at its worst. He should be incarcerated for his actions. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,810 Bob H. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,809 Linda K. This poor should be retired in a nice pasture somewhere. They should do away with these working horses. Between the hot pavement and cars and lack of food and water. These carriages should be banned. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,808 Patricia S. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,807Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,806 Luciana d. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,805 Susan J W. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,804 Kathryn R. Jail for the real animal Ian McKeever. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,803 Daniela N. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,802Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,801Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,800Anonymous 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,799 Rusell T. 0 Mar 04, 2025
16,798 Véronique A. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,797 Josianne C. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,796 Michelle H. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,795 Lynn P. OH MY GOD!! If it's hot for us it's going to be hotter for them!! I hope this carriage driver can never own another animal!!!! 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,794 Charla E. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,793 Mary W. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,792 Gail L. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,791 Mary Ann G. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,790 Aimee M. 0 Mar 03, 2025
16,789 Sharon A. Retire this horse to a sanctuary where he can have peace and rest for his remaining time on this earth 0 Mar 03, 2025