Video Shows Puppies Cruelly Hurled Into South Carolina Lake

Published: April 07, 2022 at 07:27 PM Author: PENNY EIMS

Abbeville, SC – Days ago, a man fishing from a small boat at Jim Rampey recreation park/boat ramp in Lownedsville, South Carolina, bore witness to a cruel situation that has sparked widespread outrage thanks to video evidence that he was able to capture.

The man told journalist Cody Alcorn that he was fishing last Sunday when he noticed a group of laughing men on the bank; he decided to take a closer look. The man said that he watched someone in the group hurl two pitbull puppies into the lake, explaining why he decided to get a video of what was happening:

He said he wanted to get it on video before confronting them as it would be one word against the other. It didn’t take long once they noticed him watching/recoding they took off.

Abbeville County Captain Matthew Graham was able to speak with the witness and he learned that the puppies were repeatedly hurled into the water, even though it was only captured once on video. Captain Graham commented on the situation, stating, “We’re not going to tolerate any kind of cruelty towards animals.”

The video circulated widely on social media and enough tips were made to the authorities that Captain Graham was able to confirm to Animal Victory that one man was arrested and another was identified and a warrant for his arrest has been issued. Captain Graham did not release the names of the suspects or provide information about the current status of the puppies who were thrown into the lake.

We need your signatures on the petition to help ensure that this animal cruelty case does not get swept under the rug and these individuals do not get a slap on the wrist for their vile actions. We know that people are outraged and we all want to see these men appropriately punished for what they did.

We the undersigned demand that the men responsible for repeatedly hurling these puppies into the lake are held responsible for their appalling behavior. We are petitioning for these individuals to receive the maximum punishment allowable by law and to be prohibited from owning pets in the future.

Update 4/6/2023: Animal Victory sent cover letter and petition to the judge. 

Update 1/27/2023: Animal Victory spoke to the clerk’s office, and learned that they are not on the docket yet; they’ve had their appearances, so now it is up to the solicitor when they go back to court.

Update 2/2/2023: AV spoke to the clerk’s office and they are not on the docket yet, They’ve had their appearances, so now it is up to the solicitor when they go back to court.

Update 6/09/2022: Animal Victory has learned that both defendants are due in Abbeville County Court on June 24, 2022, at 11:00 a.m. Both men have been arrested at this time. Animal Victory has sent 19,454 signatures to Solicitor Michael Black who is representing the state.

Allen‘s charges here

Hufflin‘s charges here

Update 4/8/2022: After the publication of this petition, new information regarding the case was made available to the public. On Thursday, the Anderson County Sheriff’s Office arrested Calvin Bynes Hufflin, of Anderson, for ill-treatment of animals, and seized one of the puppies (who is now in the care of a local animal shelter). An arrest warrant has been issued for Carondus Moreck Allen, of Anderson. Allen is facing the same ill-treatment of animals charge and it is believed that he is in possession of the other puppy. Anyone with information about the whereabouts of Carondus Moreck Allen is asked to contact the sheriff’s office at (864) 446-6000.

Calvin Hufflin (left) and Carondus Allen (right) (Source: Abbeville County Sheriff’s Office)

Note: Individuals are presumed innocent until being found guilty in a court of law. Animal Victory relies upon the authorities and the court system to determine guilt or innocence.


Click link below to view video.

Fox 46

CBS 17


Prior Signatures 19,950

Video Shows Puppies Cruelly Hurled Into South Carolina Lake

73 signatures = 0% of goal

Share This Petition


Latest Signatures
73 luke A. 0 Jun 02, 2024
72 Jon J. Take this pond scum out to the ocean and drop them off. Make sure it's shark infested. 0 May 28, 2024
71 Samantha H. 0 May 19, 2024
70 Melissa M. May 13, 2024
69 Jill H. May 07, 2024
68 Crystal T. May 05, 2024
67 stacy s. Apr 30, 2024
66Anonymous Need harsher laws for scum Apr 26, 2024
65 Karen C. Apr 26, 2024
64 Cynthia N. Apr 20, 2024
63 Linda A. Apr 19, 2024
62 Joannie R. Apr 19, 2024
61 terry f. Apr 17, 2024
60 Robin A. 😡😡😡😡😡 Apr 16, 2024
59 Corine C. Apr 15, 2024
58 Martine C. Apr 15, 2024
57 Rajita C. Apr 11, 2024
56 Kim A. Apr 11, 2024
55 Cindy A. Apr 10, 2024
54 anna a. Apr 09, 2024
53 Deborah C. Apr 05, 2024
52 edward h. Apr 05, 2024
51 Jacqueline M. Apr 03, 2024
50 Tammie C. Mar 28, 2024
49 Maria M. Mar 24, 2024
48 Rie M. Mar 23, 2024
47 Irene M. Mar 23, 2024
46 Raquel M. Mar 21, 2024
45 Amanda S. Mar 20, 2024
44 Leilani P. Mar 17, 2024
43Anonymous Mar 17, 2024
42 Victoria D. Mar 16, 2024
41 TERRI B. Mar 14, 2024
40 Cathy C. Mar 13, 2024
39 Melina A. Mar 13, 2024
38 danielle s. Mar 09, 2024
37 Cindy S. Mar 07, 2024
36 carol L. Mar 03, 2024
35 Trever M. Feb 27, 2024
34 Majella H. Feb 25, 2024
33 Tamela E. They need to be punished for what they did. If they did this to animals just imagine what they would do to a human. Justice needs to be served Feb 20, 2024
32 Sophie G. Feb 19, 2024
31 Cathy B. Feb 15, 2024
30 Jacqueline S. Feb 10, 2024
29 Sandra P. Feb 10, 2024
28 Pauline F. Feb 02, 2024
27 Valérie P. Feb 01, 2024
26 Shana C. Jan 26, 2024
25 Janine V. Jan 25, 2024
24 Don K. Jan 24, 2024