Father And Daughter Arrested For Burning Raccoon Alive In Dumpster

Published: September 02, 2022 at 08:04 PM Author: PENNY EIMS

Sarasota, FL – A Florida man, and his daughter, have been arrested and charged following an intensive investigation by the Sarasota Sheriff’s Office Agricultural Unit that began on August 11;  the day that a Snapchat video of a raccoon being burned alive in a dumpster began circulating online.

On Sept. 2, the sheriff’s office announced the arrest of 30-year-old Alicia Kincheloe and her father, 63-year-old Roddy Kincheloe. In a press conference led by Sheriff Kurt Hoffman, the grim details that took place on August 11 were recounted. According to Sheriff Hoffman, Roddy Kincheloe initially stabbed the raccoon with a pitchfork and left the animal for dead in a dumpster. He and his daughter went to lunch and when they returned, the raccoon was still alive. At this point, a flammable liquid was poured into the dumpster, on the raccoon who was still alive, and set on fire.

Alicia gleefully recorded the raccoon being burned to death and when it was over, she appeared to be jubilant, proudly stating that “We just toasted his a**.” Adding, “Who’s hungry?”

She proceeds to use the pitchfork to remove the raccoon’s charred body from the dumpster and disposes of it off camera. Sheriff Hoffman explained that her actions secured a charge of  Tampering with Physical Evidence, in addition to Aggravated Animal Cruelty.


Alicia’s father, Roddy, is also facing a felony charge of Aggravated Cruelty to Animals, and according to Sheriff Hoffman, this adds to his growing criminal history, which includes charges in the past for prostitution, domestic violence, drugs, and contempt of court. As Sheriff Hoffman stated in the press conference, Roddy’s extensive criminal history is “what you would expect from a scumbag” who could commit a disgusting act of animal cruelty like this.

Please add your name to the petition today! What Alicia and Roddy did to this raccoon is reprehensible and they must be held accountable for their appalling behavior. This case has garnered attention from across the nation and we want to ensure that court officials are aware of the public’s support for putting these two individuals behind bars for as long as possible.

We the undersigned demand that Alicia and Roddy Kincheloe are held responsible for cruelly burning a raccoon alive. We are petitioning for Alicia and Roddy to receive the maximum punishment allowable by law for their felony charges of Aggravated Cruelty to Animals and Alicia’s charge of Tampering With Physical Evidence. 

*Alicia and Roddy have already been released from jail on bond.

Note: Individuals are presumed innocent until they have been found guilty in a court of law. Animal Victory relies upon the authorities and the court system to determine guilt or innocence.


Sarasota Sheriff’s Office press release

SNN News

Final Update 2/23/2024: Victory! Animal Victory has learned that Roddy Kincheloe was given a 10-day suspended jail sentence. He must complete an OWP (Offender Work Program) within 120 days, otherwise he must. then serve 10 days in jail. He has a $2500 fine that must be paid within 6 months. He was sentenced to 18 months of supervised probation, and he is forbidden to own or be around animals during the duration of his probation. Animal Victory thanks everyone who signed the petition, helping to keep this case in front of court officials to prevent it from being dismissed!

Update 1/22/2024: Victory – On December 19, 2023, Alicia Kincheloe was sentenced to 45 days in an offender work program, which must be completed within 315 days of her sentence, in addition to two years of community control and three years of probation. She is required to perform 100 hours of community service, which can be started after the work offender days are completed. We are happy that this case was not thrown out and that this woman was found guilty in court! We thank everyone who took the time to sign this petition, asking for justice. We are still waiting for Roddy Kincheloe’s case outcome. 

Update 10/04/2023:  Alicia Kincheloe was found guilty of the charges of aggravated animal cruelty and tampering with evidence both of which are felonies, authorities announced, on Oct. 4. Her sentencing is on Dec 19 and she faces a maximum of five years in a state correctional facility on each of the charges.  Animal Victory is pleased that Alicia was found guilty, and we are anxiously awaiting Roddy Kincheloe’s case outcome.  His trial date is yet to be scheduled.

Update 5/11/2023: Animal Victory has learned that Alicia and Roddy Kincheloe have their jury trial set for 7/24/2023 at 9 a.m. in room 4A.

Update 2/8/2023: Animal Victory has sent the petition and signatures directly to Judge Thomas Krug.  Court has been continued to April 6, 2023, for Alica Kincheloe. CMC, and as grounds would state as follows:
1, The Defendant is not in custody.
2. The Defendant is charged with Aggravated Animal Cruelty and Evidence Tampering.
3. The State and the Defense are conducting depositions of essential witnesses on February
21, 2023.
4. This stipulation for a continuance is submitted in good faith.

Update 1/26/2023: Animal Victory sent petition and cover letter to the judge.

Update 12/19/2022: Both defendants are due in court on 02/09/2023 at 8:30 a.m. in courtroom 4A with Judge Krug Thomas.

Update 10/19/2022: Both defendants are due to appear on 12/01/2022 at 8:00 am in courtroom 4A    Alicia

Update 10/4/2022: Animal Victory has sent 16,035 signatures to State Attorney Andrew VanSickle.

Update 9/26/22: Criminal felony arraignment for both defendants is scheduled for October 14, 2022, at 9 a.m. in courtroom 4B of the Sarasota County Judicial Center. 

Update 12/19/22: The next court date for both defendants is February 9, 2023, at 8:30 a.m. in courtroom 4A with Judge Krug Thomas. 


Alicia Kinchelo

Prior Signatures 18,536

Father And Daughter Arrested For Burning Raccoon Alive In Dumpster

747 signatures = 4% of goal

Share This Petition


Latest Signatures
747 Catherine T. Feb 20, 2024
746 Sophie G. Feb 20, 2024
745 Mark R. Feb 13, 2024
744 Vanda P. Feb 13, 2024
743 Kamala S. Feb 13, 2024
742 David H. Feb 13, 2024
741 Laura B. Feb 13, 2024
740 Daisy W. Feb 13, 2024
739 Helena L. Feb 13, 2024
738 Michael C. Feb 13, 2024
737 Ruby B. Feb 13, 2024
736 Scott M. Feb 13, 2024
735 Peter S. Feb 13, 2024
734 Alison B. Feb 13, 2024
733 Paula N. Feb 13, 2024
732 Ellen C. Feb 13, 2024
731 Elizabeth R. Feb 13, 2024
730 Nathan J. Feb 13, 2024
729 Suzy K. Feb 13, 2024
728 Gillian B. Feb 13, 2024
727 Edward N. Feb 13, 2024
726 Paul J. Feb 13, 2024
725 Noreen S. Feb 13, 2024
724 Karen M. Feb 13, 2024
723 Oliver B. Feb 13, 2024
722 Sidney L. Feb 13, 2024
721 James B. Feb 13, 2024
720 Frankie B. Feb 13, 2024
719 Erin R. Feb 13, 2024
718 Leonor D. Feb 13, 2024
717 Yolanda B. Feb 13, 2024
716 Indy K. Feb 13, 2024
715 Callum B. Feb 13, 2024
714 Joanne K. Feb 13, 2024
713 Tracy J. Feb 13, 2024
712 Kelsey J. Feb 13, 2024
711 Veronica C. Feb 13, 2024
710 Brandon R. Feb 13, 2024
709 Freddie P. Feb 13, 2024
708 Comillus W. Feb 13, 2024
707 Emily B. Feb 13, 2024
706 Richard P. Feb 13, 2024
705 Sarah J. Feb 13, 2024
704 Bridget H. Feb 13, 2024
703 Mark M. Feb 13, 2024
702 Yvonne E. Feb 13, 2024
701 Zazie C. Feb 13, 2024
700 Patsy M. Feb 13, 2024
699 William B. Feb 13, 2024
698 Orla M. Feb 13, 2024